The need for open ended assignments at home and in school
Every child has an innate sense of being able to relate to the characters in the story being read or an anecdote being narrated. This is often observed in classes where the teacher asks the children to postulate the ending after narrating only half the story or gives ample room for the kids’ freedom of imagination by asking what do they think would have happened if this were not the ending. This is also found in houses where the grandmother narrates a story till the point where justice has to be meted out to the aggrieved and the child is asked to pronounce the judgment as if she were the judge.
Being given the choice to change the course of the story allows her to develop a sense of responsibility towards the characters. She also feels vindicated as she has mentally taken sides with some characters. She feels that it is her story now. She gets a feeling of having created something and her confidence level will soar high.
In the classroom this is used as a part of group discussion especially in lower classes. Today, I narrated a story and asked: What do you think would have happened if X had gone home straight after his work? I was not only surprised by the varied answers I got but also by the totally inventive ones from the usually reticent ones. They came out with fantastic ones which an adult can’t ever think of.!
This sort of behaviour never stops making me wonder. Now I have been teaching from twenty years but I am thrilled to see such responses. This is a big reward and it keeps the spirit going in spite of the body acting mulish. The day was especially busy, but this last minute perk-up was a tonic. I had to stay back longer than usual due to a meeting and the surprising thing was I was relaxed and tolerant.
Some areas where I feel one can give such open –ended tasks to young kids are:
o In stories found in the language textbooks/other storybooks
o In kids’ serials watched on TV
o In popular ‘family’ movies
o In mythological stories
o In biographies / autobiographies
o In anecdotes of famous scientists
An extension of this activity could be:
o writing out dialogues of the changed ending
o enacting it out
o organizing a debate on the merits of different endings
o hypothesizing as to why the author found this ending most suitable
Recent Comments